ZWAAGSTRA: Standardized report cards make sense in Alberta if done properly
Article content
The Smith government recently introduced Bill 35, which will enable Education Minister Demetrios Nicolaides to standardize report cards in all public and separate schools.
Advertisement 2
Article content
Currently, report card formats are left to the discretion of individual school boards, and as a result, vary widely across the province. Some school boards use traditional letter and percentage grades while others have adopted different formats including a one-to-four proficiency scale.
Article content
Recommended Videos
Article content
When introducing Bill 35, Nicolaides noted many parents are confused by report cards, particularly for elementary schools, and the government should set clear standards on how information is given to parents and guardians. There are many potential benefits to standardized report cards. Most importantly, they make it easier for parents to understand how well their children are doing. By instituting one standard report card format across the province, parents will receive the same information about their children’s academic progress regardless of where their children attend school.
Side-stepping mistakes
But Nicolaides should be careful not to repeat the errors made by other provinces, most notably B.C., where in 2023 the government replaced traditional letter and percentage grades with a proficiency scale that uses the terms “developing,” “emerging,” “proficient” and “extending” to describe academic performance on K-9 report cards.
Article content
Advertisement 3
Article content
If you find these terms confusing, you aren’t alone.
A Leger poll found B.C. parents struggled to understand what the new terms mean. Only about one-quarter of parents could correctly explain what the phrase “extending” means, while less than one-third of parents picked the correct definition of “emerging.”

Parents shouldn’t require a translation guide to interpret their kids’ report cards. And they certainly shouldn’t remain in the dark about how their children perform academically. If report card standardization means following B.C.’s example, then Alberta should stay away from it. Fortunately, there’s no indication the Smith government intends to follow B.C.’s example and will hopefully opt for traditional letter or percentage grades. In fact, the same Leger poll found the vast majority of B.C. parents had no difficulty identifying the correct meaning of traditional letter grades such as “A,” “B” and “C.”
Clearly, in Alberta with Bill 35, Education Minister Nicolaides must ensure all report cards are clear and easy to understand. And crucially, if he leaves the implementation of these changes up to provincial bureaucrats or school board administrators, he will likely undermine everything he wants to accomplish with report cards. That’s because Alberta bureaucrats will likely copy what bureaucrats in other provinces such as B.C. have done.
Advertisement 4
Article content
In short, Nicolaides must make it crystal clear that all report cards at all grade levels will use traditional letter or percentage grades, and avoid confusing terminology. Parents deserve clear and understandable progress reports about their children, not more meaningless edu-jargon.
Read More
Bill 35 has the potential to be an excellent piece of legislation. Hopefully, Minister Nicolaides provides all students and parents with the information they deserve.
Michael Zwaagstra is a senior fellow at the Fraser Institute.
Article content

