Craig Conover Says This Was His Main Insecurity in Paige DeSorbo Relationship – E! Online

Plus, when Craig noted to Paige and Madison, “She’s not really texting him back much, which is a s—ty feeling,” all they could do was laugh at the situation.

“Obviously she doesn’t like him,” Paige chimed in, to which Madison agreed with, “She’s not that into you. That’s the deal.”

In a confessional, Madison elaborated on Shep and Sienna being on totally different pages in terms of their feelings for each other.

“I think this is all a fantasy in Shep’s mind,” the 34-year-old said. “I don’t think he’s in love with the idea of love, I think that he’s in love with the way she looks. I mean, she’s stunning. I get it.”