‘Yellowstone’s Mo Brings Plenty is ‘filled with gratitude’ for ‘Marshals’ episode inspired by his nephew’s tragic death
The Yellowstone spinoff Marshals has never shied away from depicting the struggles of the Native community. As the series’ American Indian Affairs Consultant, Mo Brings Plenty works with creator Spencer Hudnut to tell these stories with authenticity and accuracy. This week’s episode, “Roughstock,” is inspired by the tragic passing of Brings Plenty’s 27-year-old nephew, Cole Brings Plenty. His 2024 death went “uninvestigated,” according to his uncle.
Brings Plenty revealed that he and his brother, Joe Brings Plenty Sr., had the chance to speak with Hudnut and the creators about their loss. “We had an opportunity to share our experience, what was going on, where we’re at, and how we’re dealing with everything,” said Brings Plenty. “They took it, and they created a beautiful storyline.”
This season, Marshals introduced Brings Plenty’s on-screen nephew, Troy (Will Strongheart), a member of the Broken Rock community who was getting his life back on track after a series of hardships before his mysterious and tragic passing. Brings Plenty knew that Strongheart was the best choice for the role. “I’ve known Will for quite a long time, and so I was honored that he had the opportunity to play my nephew in this particular situation,” said Brings Plenty. “He knew Cole on a personal level. He knew what was going on and about the struggle that our family is having in the healing process.”
Brings Plenty spoke to DECIDER over Zoom to talk about the difficult episodes, share memories of his late nephew, and tease the latest threat to Thomas Rainwater’s role as Broken Rock’s Chairman.
DECIDER: This week’s episode of Marshals was inspired by the unfortunate events involving your nephew, Cole. Did the creative team approach you about this storyline?
MO BRINGS PLENTY: They did. Cole’s father—my brother Joe—and I talked to Spencer and the writers and creators. We had an opportunity to share our experience, what was going on, where we’re at, and how we’re dealing with everything. They took it, and they created a beautiful storyline.
What were your first impressions when they gave you the script? As the series’ American Indian Affairs Consultant, what feedback were you asked to provide?
I wasn’t asked to provide feedback. However, with any script, Spencer always asks me, “Is this good?” because he comes from a place of respect and honoring others. So, after I read this particular script, my heart filled with gratitude. To be honest, not many folks would take this subject and bring it to light on the show. In the past, we talked about MMIW [Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women], MMIP [Missing and Murdered Indigenous People], and so on and so forth. However, it’s a different thing entirely to tell a story that highlights what’s really occurring throughout Indian country. I’m just very grateful.

Will Strongheart is such a charismatic actor and brings so much to the role of Troy. What was it like working with him?
I’ve known Will for quite a long time, and so I was honored that he had the opportunity to play my nephew in this particular situation because Will knew our story. He knew Cole on a personal level. He knew what was going on and about the struggle that our family is having in the healing process.
With grief, I find it’s helpful to share stories and talk about our loved ones who have passed. Did you share memories of Cole on set?
Oh, absolutely. We talked a lot about the funny things that he’d done. We talked about his kindness and his love and compassion for others. He was always quick to help anyone in need; he was always there to give a hand up to someone. It didn’t matter what nationality they were or who they were. That was Cole.
Thank you for sharing that with me. We see you perform two ceremonies in Troy’s honor in this episode: one with the family that feels like a celebration of life and then one by yourself at the end of the episode that feels incredibly intimate. What are the differences between those two rituals?
The ceremony with the people was to help them with their grieving and help them process the loss from a physical perspective. It also served as a remembrance that life is forever from a spiritual perspective. The moment when I was by myself was about me allowing myself to open up and see the other side.
Was filming this episode cathartic for you?
Yes, everyone was very supportive. People knew what was going on with me and my family. Luke Grimes, Gil Birmingham, Will Strongheart, Tatanka Means, and the crew help tell this story so beautifully. It was a very vulnerable experience because we relived a lot of the heartbreaking moments. It felt good to have a group of amazing people by my side through it all.
I also kept thinking about the other families throughout Indian Country who are going through the same thing and who have not had an opportunity to share their experience as I did. It felt like we were telling this story for them too.
I do want to talk more about the season at large. Shane Whitebear (Duke David Roberts) is the first real threat to Thomas Rainwater’s role as Chairman on Broken Rock. Why do you think the community has taken Rainwater for granted, even after he returned the Duttons’ land to the reservation?
It’s something that feels familiar. I’m glad we brought in this character, Whitebear. It’s important to show what occurs in Indian Country. There is still very little known about American Indian people from a political perspective. The outside world doesn’t know much about how our tribal councils work or the positions—like Chairman—individuals can run for. It’s awesome to be able to spotlight that on the show.
Duke is doing an amazing job as Whitebear too. I worked with Duke on another show, so it’s been fun to work with him again, but to be on opposite sides.

Gil Birmingham beautifully portrayed Rainwater’s shock when Miles broke the news that he would be endorsing Whitebear for Broken Rock Chairman. Will Mo see Miles’ decision as a betrayal as well? Or does he understand Miles’ reasoning?
Mo will not see Miles’ decision as a betrayal to the people. Even though Mo is a traditional individual, he also understands the progressive side. He has too much love for Miles. He sympathizes with him because he’s been where Miles is now. He knows what it is to be a young individual who has to make a difficult decision that may not seem appropriate at the time.
It’s fitting that Rainwater looks to tradition to bolster the future of Broken Rock by bringing back the rodeo to the reservation. As the Director of Team Culture with the PBR’s Arizona Ridge Riders, how excited were you about this development?
My involvement with PBR and the Arizona Ridge Riders was part of the inspiration. It’s been wonderful to be able to bring that storyline to life. A lot of rodeos occur on the reservations. It’s wonderful to have that tradition on our show.
Lastly, your old Yellowstone star Jefferson White is reprising his role as Jimmy on an upcoming episode of Marshals. What was it like to be back on set with him?
It’s a blessing. I love Jefferson. Jimmy’s a great character, and people will be really excited to see him in action again. I loved it.